agent login


  • slideshow01
  • slideshow02
  • slideshow03
  • slideshow04
  • slideshow05
  • slideshow06
  • slideshow07
  • slideshow08
  • slideshow09
  • slideshow10
slideshow011 slideshow022 slideshow033 slideshow044 slideshow055 slideshow066 slideshow077 slideshow088 slideshow099 slideshow1010

COVID-19 Response

Through the evolving pandemic, our purpose remains clear; we are here to protect and serve the needs of our members. With our office location now closed to the public, we continue to maintain operations and provide timely service with 90% of our workforce working remotely. We are confident that we have the technology in place to continue working in this new way for the foreseeable future. Please continue to call our usual number during business hours: 717-336-6962 or email us at If you have a claim to file you can still do so by calling our Claims Department. Our Claims team are fully functional and able to process claims from first notice of loss to final resolutions. You can be assured we will remain focused on our purpose and deliver on our promise to be here for our members and agents.


Since 1895 we have been serving our policyholders' insurance needs

In the beginning, our Founders saw a need for rural Fire Insurance coverage that established Companies could not or would not write. We began by writing fire only insurance coverage. As times changed we expanded the types of coverage we offered as well. Today we offer the following package and monoline policies:

  • Commercial Lines
  • Liability
  • Umbrella
  • Homeowners
  • Mobile Homeowners
  • Farmowners

We pride ourselves in being a big enough company to offer a full line of services and yet small enough to give you the personal touch you deserve.

Reamstown Mutual Insurance Company • 625 W Main Street • PO Box 339 • New Holland, PA 17557
Toll Free: (888) 764-7232 • Local: (717) 336-6962 • Fax: (717) 336-5764 •

This website is not an insurance policy. The information in this site may or may not be included in your actual policy.
Differences are dependent on the type of coverages that you select.
Please refer to your policy for specific coverages or contact your agent for assistance.


© 2021, Reamstown Mutual Insurance Company. All Rights Reserved.